Chirre Castillo Elmer Atilio

DOI: https://doi.org.10.59427/rcli/2026/v26cs.178-188

The research conducted aimed to analyze the implications of the principle of specialty in international legal cooperation in criminal matters, considering its relevance in the face of the constant challenge of transnational organized crime and the need to ensure effective prosecution while respecting state autonomy, procedural guarantees, and fundamental rights. The research employed a qualitative approach, was basic in nature, and used a naturalistic paradigm with a phenomenological design. Five lawyers with a high degree of specialization in international legal cooperation in criminal matters, selected through purposive non-probability sampling. The interview technique was used, and the instrument applied was a guide consisting of eight open-ended questions. The data was examined through a qualitative thematic study, considering the categories of the principle of specialty and international legal cooperation. Taking into account the results obtained, it is evident that the principle of specialty is limiting the application of the requesting State’s right to punish (ius puniendi), which prevents the unilateral expansion of prosecution for prior acts other than those permitted. Furthermore, the specialists emphasized the importance of duly protecting state sovereignty, guaranteeing due process, and strengthening legal certainty. Regarding extradition, the requirement for a series of supplementary permits when it is necessary to extend the criminal charges has been identified. In terms of international legal cooperation, the importance of complying with the established conditions on mutual legal assistance for the use of information and all evidentiary elements has been highlighted. It has been concluded that the proper application of the parameters established by the principle of specialty will contribute to strengthening trust between States and the validity of cooperation in criminal matters between them, facilitating a harmonized fight against impunity while respecting all fundamental legal guarantees.

Pag 178-188